asiaone
Diva
updated 18 Feb 2014, 07:35
Login password
Sat, Feb 28, 2009
The New Paper
Email Print Decrease text size Increase text size
Kelly Poon's 'comment' on Taiwanese show draws criticism
by Tan Kee Yun

SHE admits her command of Mandarin is not fantastic.

But local singer Kelly Poon insists she would never make her country look bad.

The 25-year-old is fending off criticisms that she had 'shamed Singapore' on a Taiwanese variety show.

On the show called Variety Big Brother, Kelly was among a group of celebrities who were asked by host Chang Fei to come up with a Chinese idiom to praise a performance they had witnessed.

The episode, which was recorded in October last year, was aired here last Sunday on StarHub Cable Channel 56.

On her turn, instead of coming up with an idiom, she said with gusto: 'Fei chang li hai!' ('very amazing' in Chinese).

When this was rejected, she allegedly retorted that 'there are no Chinese idioms in Singapore', reported Shin Min Daily News.

Singaporean netizens who had seen the show blasted her, saying that 'not only has she shamed herself, she has shamed the whole of Singapore'.

One netizen angrily pointed out that 'every Singaporean Chinese who went through their O-level examinations would at least have to learn and memorise 100 idioms', so how could she say there are no idioms in Singapore?

Popular forum Hardware Zone was rife with angry remarks too, ranging from how she has 'thrown Singapore's face away' to her being a 'national disgrace'.

But in a phone interview with The New Paper yesterday, she denied making the 'idiom' remark.

'It wasn't me'

'It wasn't from me at all,' she said with a sigh. 'It was another Taiwanese female actress. It's just that when we were recording that episode, I really didn't catch her saying it.

'If I had, of course I would have jumped up instantly and shouted an idiom on the spot to prove her wrong!'

She said: 'I went through the Singapore education system, studied Chinese as my mother tongue, and I would never put my own country in a state of shame.'

As for her boo-boo in offering an expression instead of an idiom, she said she had 'tried too hard' to be 'funny' by playing on Chang Fei's name - hence 'Fei chang li hai'.

'I wanted to create more laughs, but in retrospect, maybe I overdid it.'

To bloggers who have told her to 'brush up on her Chinese' before venturing into the Taiwan and China markets, Kelly said she 'is constantly working hard to master the language'.

The singer hopes Singaporeans do not take everything they see on Taiwanese programmes too seriously.

The incident echoed a similar one last February.

Taiwanese actor Shen Dong-Ching also incurred the wrath of Singapore netizens when he went on a popular Taiwanese talkshow and started mimicking 'the way Singaporeans speak English'.

Adding fuel to the fire was a Taiwanese English teacher, who claimed Singaporeans pronounced 'pregnant' as 'pegnant'.

Both subsequently apologised.

This article was first published in The New Paper.

readers' comments
Stop complaining!
What is wrong with you people out there?
Managed to see the mistakes of others but never once yourself!
Posted by on Sat, 28 Feb 2009 at 14:40 PM
Dear fellow Singaporeans... please wake up. For many of us, we just have to admit that language is not our forte, be it Mandarin, Cantonese or English. So what's wrong if others mimic the way we speak? It is true that some of us pronounce pregnant as "pegnant". It is also true many of us cannot spout Chinese idioms to save our lives. If others laugh at our language, it only shows that we have to brush up! There's no point in being so childish and defensive and end up not improving ourselves.
Posted by bienni2008 on Sat, 28 Feb 2009 at 14:17 PM
well I remember SHE making the same disparaging remarks about Singapore but look what happened a year later! THEY ARE NOW ON OUR SINGAPORE STAMPS AND THE FIRST SINGERS AS WELL! i guess Singaporeans are a forgiving lot.
Posted by on Sat, 28 Feb 2009 at 12:11 PM
Bcoz of you .................,
Shame on us !!!!!!!!! not you.
the more you talk ,the more you are in trouble.
Just sing and smile will do don't talk too much.
Posted by smartlow on Sat, 28 Feb 2009 at 11:17 AM

asiaone
Copyright © 2014 Singapore Press Holdings Ltd. Co. Regn. No. 198402868E. All rights reserved.